ANSWERS: 38
  • Personally i dont go for that whole dolled up look, anybody can look good when they have on their full armoury of makeup so to me that's nothing over special, i spend more time checking out the 'everyday' looking woman cause if you look good in just your scrubs then you have beauty beyond measure, nothing beats natural beauty.
  • The former
  • If I were in high school, I would probably go for the ponytail first. They were fun to grab a hold of when I was kid. Some of those girls could sure throw a good punch.
  • The dolled up on unless the ponytailed one was wearing just a t-shirt with those tennis shoes. I think a girl wearing only a tshirt is really sexy.
  • I'm with coolmo. Natural beauty will always trump the fakeup.
  • Depends on the girl. A girl dolled up has caught my eye before and once at the super market I couldn't stop starring at this woman in sweat pants and a wife beater.
  • The dolled up one might catch my eye first, but that doesn't mean I would find her more attractive that the one wearing tennis shoes.
  • It's really all down to what she looks like. Face, proportions, hair type, etc..
  • I always base my opinion on the eyes first so which ever one had better eyes.
  • That all depends... For example : Scenario #1 - Rosie O'Donnell is just about as dolled up as she's ever gonna get wearing a nice dress & high heels. Even if she was 100% heterosexual, I'd rather kiss an angry badger right on the lips! Scenario #2 - Katherine Zeta Jones -or-( Jennifer Love Hewitt ) is wearing her hair pulled back in a messy ponytail and wearing tennis shoes, jeans & a t-shirt. There's no way either of them could keep from looking gorgeous. See where I'm going with this? I could care less what a woman is wearing. It's the woman that catches my eye ;-)
  • There should have been a third option... a girl with nothing on.... a girl dolled up may have a bod which would look disgusting without the doll up and the girl with the tennis shoes may have the ugliest feet I would have ever seen... so seeing is believing...
  • Well, it would depend what colors their wearing and how tall they are (i would notice a giant person first), or if one was loud. Also, if one was closer to me than the other the closer one would probably catch my eye first.
  • Probably the one who is all dolled up just because you dont see that too much. But I think I would find more attractive the one in the ponytail and tennis shoes. I am not a huge fan of girly girls with all the makeup and pink and all that crap.
  • While I do enjoy seeing a girl all dolled up, I prefer to see it as a minority. Ponytails and tennis shoes scream "It's go time"... and is very, very attractive. It says "Let's ride a motorcycle, catch a fish, rappell a cliff, go for a hike, eat lunch on a blanket under a tree, catch a nap in the long grass and wrestle in the creek"... Then we can go home, catch a shower and go put our worn out bodies in a theatre seat somewhere. edit**** My favorite part on a woman's body is her neck... a ponytail with loose hairs hanging down a luscious neck line puts me into a drooling kniption fit.
  • Hey, We'll take both of them. We'll chase anything in a skirt even Scotsmen are not safe around us!!!! XP
  • I dress both ways. I get more head turns when I'm dolled up. FACT!
  • I tend to like the girls who are more casual. Dressed up is nice, but if she's dressed up all the time, it kind of screams "high maintennance". Girls are sexy in t-shirts, especially white t-shirts or tank tops. I saw a girl at a pub Monday night wearing a white tank top and jeans, and I was absolutely enthralled. :)
  • i like myself "dolled up" better :) .. yeaaah, i'm a girl .. but i had to get my two cents in
  • I like a girl who is just as gorgeous when I wake up next to her as when she is dolled up for a night on the town!! If she's jogging down the street in ponytail and shoes or if she's ready to hit the club good looks catch the eye the ensuing conversation sums up if I like her or she really is just a dumb barbie doll... The latter is just as important!!
  • I'm a fan of all dolled up. My current girlfriend caught my eye when she was just wearing normal gym clothes, though, so what do I know?
  • I have to be honest probably the girl all dolled up would catch my eye way before the girl in tennis shoes and a messy ponytail. That however doesn't mean I couldn't see the girl with the messy pony tail as a beautiful person in time if I took the time to get to know her.
  • the girl in tennis shoes was in my mind before I even saw the other girl, who wouldn`t get the time of day from me.
  • The girl all dolled up would interest me for a one nighter only and she would be too HM, the girl in the tennis shoes would probably be more fun and a keeper.
  • A sexy girl all dolled up at a bar. Wannna meet me out, I'm going drinking.
  • im a girl that doesnt dress up alot. my sneakers or sporty flip flops are ALL i wear. im ur average basketball gurl. i hang out with guys more than girls cause i hate PREPS! i like lookin cute with out gettin all dolled up. but from wat i can tell, guys definately go for the comfortable cutie... lol
  • Same girl? Probably be more likely to strike up a conversation with the low key one. Something less intimidating, about her. Also, (and I know this is a broad sweeping generalization, but it is how I FEEL...) the girl who's all dressed up reminds me of all the party girls who've snubbed me, or not been able to carry on a conversation, because they're too focussed on being girly or getting attention. Not to say either's better, but that would be my first impression...
  • The girl in the heels would definitely catch my eye first.
  • It depends on the location...too much glam in the wrong setting signals "I'm a slut looking to get laid" whereas a ponytail and tennis shoes looks hot in a local bar setting. Guys looks at it differently based on the setting. But seriously though, you can never go wrong by wearing a great set of heels in the bedroom scenario.
  • I love them all dolled up. It shows me she takes pride in herself. She wants to look good not only for me but for herself as well.
  • the girl with high heels every time
  • Outward apperance is not all that important to me. What attracts me is a womans attitude, friendliness, self-assuredness. I do love to see my lady all dressed up, but reality is, most of the time, i see her in sweat pants and tank top. She is as beautiful just waking up or going out on the town.
  • As a girl, I've noticed that I get attention both ways. One time I was at Home Depot after not showered all day, no make-up, greasy hair in a bun on my head, baggy and dirty sweatpants and some guy followed me to my car in his truck as I was carting out a bunch of house plants and he said, "I'm sorry to bother you, but... you are INCREDIBLY sexy!" Who knows.
  • messy ponytail it shows me shes not high maintance and can let herself be natural
  • the dressed up girl of course
  • lol i like to dress both ways depends on how i feel. when i am dolled up i get attention and when i am dressed down i get attention. so it just depends on what crowd of men you are around at that time.
  • Likely, the girl who's all dolled up would catch my attention first but the very first words that come out of her mouth will determine whether or not she'll keep it.
  • Hair up and JUST tennis shoes,,that would catch my eye...lol

Copyright 2018, Wired Ivy, LLC

Answerbag | Terms of Service | Privacy Policy